Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Ham & Provolone Sub
Cheese Ravioli
Cheese Tortellini With Pink Sauce
Ziti With Meat Sauce
About
Goodfella's Pizza & Subs
Welcome to Goodfella's Pizza & Subs, a delightful pizza haven located at 2260 Country Club Rd #107, St Paul, TX. This charming establishment brings a slice of New Jersey flavor right to the heart of Texas, and it is evident from the moment you step in. The inviting atmosphere, paired with a warm welcome from the friendly staff, sets the stage for a memorable dining experience.
If you're here for the pizza, you're in for a treat. According to recent customer reviews, the cheese pizza is a family favorite, known for its unique puffy yet thin crust that captures the essence of what pizza should be. Patrons rave about how once you try a slice, you'll be hooked. The crust manages to strike the perfect balance—not overly crispy like traditional thin crusts, yet undeniably satisfying with each bite.
Goodfella's also offers a delectable variety of pastas to cater to all taste buds. From the Ziti Al Vodka with Mild Pink Sauce to Spaghetti with Meatballs, each dish is crafted with care and attention. Don’t overlook the cheesy Manicotti or the fresh Ravioli with Pesto Sauce, which are both sure to delight!
For those seeking something a bit different, the bowls serve as a hearty alternative. Options like the Sausage & Green Peppers Bowl and the Meatball Bowl offer gluten-free goodness, ensuring everyone can find their perfect dish.
And what’s a meal without dessert? Indulge in their irresistible Cinnamon Knots or the rich Chocolate Cheesecake. Customers have shared how these sweets provide the perfect ending to a great meal, leaving everyone satisfied and smiling.
Goodfella's Pizza & Subs is not just about the food; it’s about the experience. The kindness of the manager and the crew makes every visit feel homey and welcoming. Lisa, who visited on Mother’s Day, remarked how the ambiance and the nostalgic counter display reminded her of classic pizza shops back in Jersey. It’s a place that genuinely cares about its customers, making each visit feel special.
For pizza lovers, pasta aficionados, and anyone craving a hearty meal, Goodfella's Pizza & Subs is a must-try. With great prices, friendly service, and a menu that leaves you wanting more, this little gem is ready to charm your taste buds. Make a stop here, and you won’t be disappointed!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Garlic knots with a side of Alfredo sauce are hands down the best! Fried mushrooms were wonderful!! The cheese pizza is a family favorite and every time we get together with friends we get the cheese pizza to go. After one slice of the cheese pizza you will be hooked! The pizza crust is different from everywhere else. It has a perfect puffy crust but it's thin. However it is not crispy like your traditional thin crust. Give it a try and you will not be disappointed!! ”
“ It's a wonderful and small place for pizza, pasta and stuff. The manager is one of the kindest and most friendly soul you'll ever meet in life. He's there every day too and works the shop with his crew who are very friendly as well. ”
“ Nice little pizza dive with great prices and staff ”
“ Food is always delicious. Dine in is a must try experience. They're great people, and it's very welcoming. You can tell they love what they do. ”
“ Stopped in for mother's Day lunch with two of my daughters. We were greeted with a warm welcome and the counter display of pizza garlic knots and strombolis brought me back to New Jersey pizza shops. The pizza was delicious, garlic knots were great and stromboli was full of lots of flavor! Very friendly atmosphere, you can tell they care about their customers! We will definitely be returning! ”
“ Only been in Wylie a couple months but I’ve tried many pizza places. Im a Chicago kid with a love for deep dish. I did a search and this place came up. Thank you Google! Pizza is amazing, staff was great when I came to pick up and I will be back. If you’re looking for pizza that is way above any I’ve had. ”
“ Tonight I tried the deep dish and quite an amazing experience it was I absolutely loved it and the people of Goodfellas’ are always the best. Craig the owner is one of the nicest guy and he’s always there. Straight up dedication. Still the best pizza spot in Texas, no doubt and their pasta dishes are bomb as well. I’ve been in Texas for 1 year 3 months and I’m “JerseyAdam in Texas”. Lived in LA also for 19 years. This place is one of the best in 20 years. Check out that pic ”
“ My mom loved the eggplant and pasta dish , I had the Chicken franchese, It was excellent ”